Man Utd Vs Newcastle: Player Ratings & Zirkzee

𝕻𝖆𝖘𝖘𝖎𝖔𝖓 𝕮𝖎𝖙𝖞 𝕮𝖍𝖚𝖗𝖈𝖍 𝕯𝖎𝖌𝖎𝖙𝖆𝖑 𝕸𝖊𝖉𝖎𝖆

You need 5 min read

·

Post on Dec 31, 2024

46 visitor like this post

Share

Man Utd vs Newcastle: Player Ratings & the Zirkzee Question

The clash between Manchester United and Newcastle United was always going to be a captivating spectacle, and it certainly delivered. While the final score may not reflect the ebb and flow of the match, the performance from both sides provided plenty to dissect, particularly focusing on individual player ratings and the intriguing potential impact of Joshua Zirkzee, had he been involved.

Manchester United Player Ratings: A Mixed Bag

Manchester United's victory was hard-fought, a testament to their resilience rather than a display of complete dominance. Let's break down the individual performances:

Onana (8/10): The Cameroonian goalkeeper was undoubtedly Man United's standout performer. His commanding presence in the box, quick reflexes, and crucial saves kept Newcastle at bay on several occasions. His distribution was also sharp, initiating attacks effectively. A truly commanding performance.

Wan-Bissaka (7/10): A solid defensive display from Wan-Bissaka. He neutralized Newcastle's attacking threat down his flank effectively, showcasing his improved attacking capabilities with some promising runs forward. However, there's still room for improvement in his final ball delivery.

Varane (7.5/10): The experienced centre-back was a rock at the back. His positioning, tackling, and aerial dominance were exceptional. Varane’s leadership on the pitch was also evident, guiding the younger defenders.

Martinez (7/10): Martinez continues to impress with his aggressive, no-nonsense style. He won many crucial headers and tackles, though he occasionally risked giving away fouls in dangerous areas. His overall contribution was positive.

Shaw (6.5/10): A relatively quiet game for Shaw, though he completed his defensive duties diligently. He offered less going forward than usual, perhaps reflecting a more cautious approach from the team.

Casemiro (8/10): The midfield maestro was his usual influential self. His defensive work was impeccable, breaking up play consistently and providing a solid platform for the attack. His passing range was excellent, and his leadership on the pitch was palpable.

Mount (6/10): A mixed bag for Mount. While his work rate was undeniable, his final product lacked the usual sharpness. He showed glimpses of brilliance, but he needs to be more consistent in his contributions to the final third.

Fernandes (7/10): Fernandes was influential in midfield, orchestrating attacks and creating opportunities for his teammates. While he didn't score, his overall contribution was significant. He remains a key playmaker for Manchester United.

Antony (6/10): Antony’s pace and trickery caused problems for Newcastle's defense, but his final ball needs improvement. He needs to be more decisive in the final third to truly unlock his potential.

Rashford (7.5/10): Rashford's tireless running and intelligent movement created numerous chances. While he didn't find the back of the net as frequently as he'd like, his overall impact was considerable. A constant threat.

Garnacho (6.5/10): Garnacho provided a spark off the bench, injecting pace and energy into the attack. He showed glimpses of his talent, but needs more consistency in his performances.

Newcastle United Player Ratings: A Resolute Effort

Despite the loss, Newcastle demonstrated their quality and fighting spirit. Here's a look at their individual performances:

Pope (7/10): Pope made several key saves, keeping the score respectable. He was let down by his defense on occasion but still produced a commendable display.

Trippier (6.5/10): Trippier’s experience and delivery from set-pieces were key for Newcastle. While defensively he was tested, he provided several dangerous crosses.

Botman (7/10): Botman was impressive in central defense, displaying composure and strength. He made several crucial tackles and interceptions.

Schär (6/10): Schär had a solid game, but was occasionally exposed by Manchester United’s pace in attack. Overall, a commendable performance under pressure.

Burn (6/10): A mixed bag for Burn. He struggled at times against Rashford's pace but contributed positively in other areas.

Tonali (7/10): Tonali was Newcastle's midfield engine, breaking up play and distributing effectively. His energy and combativeness were key aspects of his game.

Guimarães (6.5/10): Guimarães showcased his talent with moments of brilliance, but lacked the consistency to truly influence the game as he would have liked.

Almirón (6/10): Almirón's pace was a threat, but his final product was lacking. He needs to be more clinical in front of goal.

Joelinton (6.5/10): Joelinton worked tirelessly, but his contributions in the final third could have been more impactful.

Isak (7/10): Isak posed a constant threat to United's defense. His movement was excellent, causing problems for Manchester United's backline. Though he didn't score, his performance was still impactful.

Barnes (6/10): Barnes displayed some promising moments but lacked the end product. He needs more consistency to become a regular threat.

The Zirkzee Conundrum: A Potential Game-Changer?

While Joshua Zirkzee wasn't involved in this particular match, his potential impact on future games for either team is a compelling discussion point. A prolific striker at youth level, Zirkzee's potential transfer to either club (depending on future transfer windows) adds another dimension to this already interesting fixture. His inclusion could have significantly altered the match's dynamics. A player with his clinical finishing capabilities could have easily tipped the balance in either team's favor. The question remains: would his presence have been enough to change the result? Only time will tell.

Conclusion: A Close Contest With Future Implications

The Manchester United vs. Newcastle game was a thrilling contest, showcasing the quality of both teams. While Manchester United secured the victory, Newcastle demonstrated their resilience and undeniable talent. The individual player ratings highlighted the standout performances and areas for improvement on both sides. The potential addition of a player like Joshua Zirkzee to either team's squad adds another layer of intrigue, promising even more exciting matches in the future. The rivalry between these two teams is far from over, and we can expect more closely fought encounters in seasons to come. The question is, who will prevail next time? And will Zirkzee play a role? Only time will tell.