QB Succession Plans: Cousins Benching Shows Flaws

𝕻𝖆𝖘𝖘𝖎𝖔𝖓 𝕮𝖎𝖙𝖞 𝕮𝖍𝖚𝖗𝖈𝖍 𝕯𝖎𝖌𝖎𝖙𝖆𝖑 𝕸𝖊𝖉𝖎𝖆

You need 5 min read

·

Post on Dec 22, 2024

49 visitor like this post

Share

QB Succession Plans: Cousins Benching Shows Flaws in NFL Strategies

The Minnesota Vikings' decision to bench veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins in the final game of the regular season sparked a renewed debate about the complexities and potential pitfalls of quarterback succession plans in the NFL. While the move may seem inconsequential on the surface – a meaningless game against a weak opponent – it highlights some significant flaws in how many teams approach the crucial task of grooming their future signal-callers. The Cousins benching isn't just about one game; it’s a microcosm of the larger issues surrounding QB development and the often-hasty decisions made in the face of uncertainty.

The Illusion of Seamless Transitions

Many NFL franchises operate under the illusion that transitioning from one quarterback to another is a simple, straightforward process. The reality is far more nuanced and often fraught with challenges. Developing a young quarterback requires more than just drafting a highly touted prospect; it requires a comprehensive strategy that accounts for various factors, including:

• Playing Time: Young quarterbacks need significant game experience to develop their skills and instincts. Sitting on the bench for years, only to be thrown into the fire when the pressure is immense, rarely yields positive results. The "redshirt" approach, prevalent in college football, rarely translates effectively to the NFL.

• Coaching and Development: A young quarterback needs dedicated coaching and a supportive environment to learn and grow. This extends beyond just offensive coordinators; it includes individual tutors, film study sessions, and a willingness from the coaching staff to tailor the offensive scheme to the quarterback's strengths. The Vikings' approach, while seemingly prioritizing the future, lacked the long-term planning needed to ensure Cousins' replacement was truly ready.

• Offensive Line Protection: A shaky offensive line can derail the development of even the most talented quarterbacks. Consistent pressure can lead to poor decision-making, increased turnovers, and a lack of confidence. A team's investment in offensive line talent is crucial for supporting young QBs.

• Offensive Scheme: A simplistic, predictable offense may be necessary for young quarterbacks to learn the basics, but a team should aim to gradually increase complexity as the quarterback's skillset develops. A rigid offense can stunt growth and limit a quarterback's potential.

The Cousins Case: A Symptom, Not the Disease

The Vikings' decision to bench Cousins, while seemingly progressive in its intention to give the backup quarterback experience, ultimately exposed several systemic issues:

• Lack of Long-Term Vision: The Vikings' approach suggested a lack of a clear, long-term plan for their quarterback position. The benching felt reactive rather than proactive, implying a deficiency in their pre-season evaluation of their quarterback depth chart. Did they truly believe their backup was ready for significant game time, or was this a knee-jerk reaction to ensure playing time for a specific player?

• Missed Opportunities for Development: The final regular season game represented a missed opportunity to evaluate the backup quarterback under pressure. While the opponent's strength was negligible, the game's environment still provided valuable experience in managing a game's flow, making in-game adjustments, and dealing with the heightened pressure of a live NFL game, even if the stakes were minimal.

• Potential Impact on Team Morale: Benching a veteran quarterback who's been a consistent performer, even in a meaningless game, can have a negative impact on team morale. It sends a message that player performance, even consistent excellence, is secondary to arbitrary strategic decisions. This lack of player respect can permeate the entire team.

• The Risk of Inconsistent Messaging: The benching created inconsistent messaging about team priorities. Were the Vikings focused on winning games, developing young talent, or something else entirely? The lack of clarity can confuse players, coaches, and fans alike.

Beyond the Vikings: A Broader NFL Problem

The Vikings' situation is not an isolated incident. Many NFL teams struggle to navigate the complexities of quarterback succession. The pressure to win immediately often overshadows the long-term benefits of patient quarterback development. Drafting a high-profile quarterback doesn't guarantee success; it requires a comprehensive, well-executed plan.

Common Flaws in NFL QB Succession Plans:

• Rushing the Process: Too often, teams are impatient and try to force a young quarterback into action before they're ready. This often leads to poor performance, diminished confidence, and ultimately, a shortened career.

• Ignoring the Supporting Cast: A young quarterback needs a strong supporting cast, including a reliable offensive line, talented receivers, and a well-designed offensive scheme. Neglecting these elements hampers a young QB's development.

• Lack of Continuity in Coaching: Frequent coaching changes can disrupt a young quarterback's development, leading to inconsistencies in offensive schemes and coaching philosophies.

• Overreliance on Pre-Draft Evaluations: While pre-draft scouting is important, it's not a foolproof system. Teams need to continuously evaluate their quarterbacks throughout their development.

Building a Successful Succession Plan: Lessons Learned

The Vikings' experience provides valuable lessons for other NFL teams looking to build successful quarterback succession plans:

• Long-Term Vision is Key: Develop a comprehensive, long-term plan that accounts for all aspects of quarterback development, from drafting to mentorship to game experience.

• Patient Development: Be patient and allow young quarterbacks time to learn and grow. Rushing the process can have detrimental effects.

• Invest in the Supporting Cast: Ensure the young quarterback has the necessary support system, including a strong offensive line, talented receivers, and a well-designed offensive scheme.

• Consistency in Coaching: Maintain coaching continuity to ensure consistent messaging and coaching philosophies.

• Regular Evaluation: Continuously evaluate the young quarterback's progress and make necessary adjustments to the plan.

• Prioritize Development Over Short-Term Gains: The focus should be on long-term development rather than short-term wins, especially regarding critical positions like quarterback.

The Cousins benching serves as a cautionary tale, highlighting the challenges and potential pitfalls of quarterback succession plans in the NFL. Building a successful plan requires a long-term vision, patience, and a comprehensive approach that accounts for all the factors contributing to a quarterback's success. Ignoring these lessons can lead to missed opportunities, wasted talent, and ultimately, a less successful team. The future of any NFL franchise often hinges on the effective management of its quarterback position. The Vikings' experience underscores the need for a more thoughtful, strategic, and less impulsive approach to this crucial aspect of team building.